Frogs thrive in agricultural areas.
In 2007, EPA concluded that "atrazine does not adversely affect amphibian gonadal development based on a review of laboratory and field studies...” In a white paper issued by EPA in 2012 prior to a Science Advisory Panel (SAP), the Agency indicated that it “has been unable to find any clear and consistent effects correlated to atrazine exposures across amphibian species, in spite of the large number of studies that purport that such effects exist…” Based on EPA guidance, two large-scale studies (Kloas, 2009) were conducted in separate laboratories using 3,200 frogs and 100,000 tissue samples to determine whether or not atrazine has an impact on growth, development, survival, or sexual differentiation in frogs. EPA audited and inspected the data from these studies and found: “The data are sufficiently robust to outweigh previous efforts to study the potential effects of atrazine on amphibian gonadal development” and "there is no compelling reason to pursue additional testing."
Furthermore the one study in which all of the identified test design elements were accounted for remains the one that was conducted in response to the DCI [Data Call-In] in 2004, which was comprised of two studies conducted in parallel at two different laboratories. This study did not demonstrate any “consistent, concentration-dependent effects of atrazine on sexual development, metamorphosis, growth and survival of X. laevis [a type of frog] at atrazine concentrations of 0.01 to 100 μg/L.” This concentration range is considered to represent the upper limit of environmentally relevant exposures. In addition, a survey of frog populations in forests, agricultural areas, suburbs and cities in the U.S. Northeast found that frogs were thriving in rural, agricultural communities, while frogs in cities and suburbs had much higher deformity rates. A similar survey conducted by Prof. Tyrone Hayes of University of California, Berkeley with scientists at the U.S. Geological Survey, of the native northern leopard frog shows that it continues to thrive in areas where atrazine is heavily used, including in irrigation ditches next to cornfields in the U.S. Midwest. Collectively, the extensive body of research indicates that atrazine does not adversely affect fish, amphibians and reptiles at environmentally relevant concentrations (<100 mg atrazine/L) when considered under a Quantitative Weight of Evidence (QWoE) framework (Van Der Kraak et al., 2014; Hanson et al., 2019).